Colton Underwood, 31
1
Hadley Walts, 22
2
Tiara Hodge, 33
3
Ben Higgins, 33
4
Amber Portwood, 32
5
Lexus Scheller, 21
6
Shea Couleé, 34
7
Teddi Mellencamp Arroyave, 41
8
Shanley McIntee, 33
9
Blair St. Clair, 27
10
Jessica Figueroa, 30
11
Jenna Cooper, 33
12
Trista Sutter, 50
13
Austin Armacost, 34
14
Gary Shirley, 36
15
Hayden Parker Weaver, 30
16
Michelle Oakley, 53
17
Billie Lee, 39
18
Shayden Massey, 24
19
Trevin Alford, 16
20
Rod Bullock, 44
21
Karen Laine, 60
22
Elizabeth Carroll, 66
23
Laura Boneham, 54
24
Born in Indiana
Most Popular Reality Stars
